Most of the staff running three Alaska newspapers in Homer, Kenai-Soldotna and Juneau resigned in protest Monday. The decision came after the corporate owner of the Homer News, Kenai Peninsula Clarion and Juneau Empire forced revisions to a story after pressure from a Republican state lawmaker.
The four journalists — Regional Editor Erin Thompson, Clarion Sports and Features Editor Jeff Helminiak, Clarion Senior Reporter Jake Dye and Homer News Reporter Chloe Pleznac — signed a joint resignation letter castigating Alabama-based Carpenter Media Group for its decision to modify the story without consulting the reporter or editor responsible, saying it “gravely undermined” their ability to do their jobs.
“Though this decision is extremely painful for us, it is not difficult,” they wrote. “We cannot do our jobs knowing that pressure from an elected official can mean our stories are edited without prior consultation with us.”
On Wednesday, Homer Republican Rep. Sarah Vance posted a letter on state letterhead to her official Facebook page objecting to a Homer News article about a memorial for the slain activist Charlie Kirk. She highlighted a paragraph that identified Kirk as a “far-right” activist with “racist and controversial views.” Vance accused the paper of bias and said she was “aware of” a campaign to boycott Homer News advertising.
In an interview, Dye said his resignation was a long time coming. He’s repeatedly complained about mismanagement since Carpenter Media bought the paper out of insolvency last year, he said. But capitulating to pressure from a state lawmaker, going over the editor’s and reporter’s heads, Dye said, was a step too far.
A day later, the story was removed, edited, stripped of a byline and reposted — without, Dye said, any consultation with the newsroom. Vance subsequently thanked Carpenter Media in a Facebook post for responding to her concerns after a discussion with the paper’s publisher.
“Sarah Vance sent one letter on a Wednesday night — she probably didn't even put a ton of thought into it — and got our story changed,” he said. “What stops her from doing that the next time? What stops anybody?”
Vance and Carpenter Media did not respond to interview requests.
Dye hasn’t gotten answers on what Vance asked for, and what Carpenter agreed to, he said.
“I feel like I should be able to trust Carpenter Media,” he said. “That's just not what happened in this case.”
The mass resignations leave the three papers with just two reporters: one for the Homer News and another with the Juneau Empire, Dye said.
Veteran Alaska journalist and University of Alaska Fairbanks professor Paula Dobbyn said she was shocked by the episode — not just by Vance’s pressure campaign, but Carpenter’s decision to give in.
“We pride ourselves as Americans on having freedom of the press,” she said. “For an ownership group to just go ahead and alter a news story based on a complaint by a politician without consulting the editor or the reporter, I just think was appalling, and I fully support the staff for not putting up with it.”
It’s especially alarming given the fragile state of journalism in Alaska, she said. It’s not clear what’ll happen to the papers with most of the editorial staff gone, and Dobbyn said she’s concerned the exodus will leave Kenai Peninsula communities less informed.
“I certainly hope that the Kenai is not going to become another news desert, because, you know, people have the right to be informed,” she said. “There's a lot that's happening down there, and we certainly need coverage of it.”
Dobbyn said she hoped another news source would fill the void. She pointed to the nonprofit Juneau Independent, a nonprofit online outlet founded by the former editor of another Carpenter paper, the Juneau Empire, who also resigned over disagreements with management.
As much as he loves journalism, Dye said he’s not planning to follow a similar path.
“I don't think the others are really interested in that. We certainly don't have the money for that,” he said. “I, unfortunately, kind of think this is it.”
Dye hopes Carpenter Media will invest in its Alaska papers, he said, but he’s not optimistic. He said management told the newsroom that the Clarion was losing money, but had not outlined plans to turn the struggling outlet around.
“Until this last week, they (didn’t) really interact with us,” he said. “I keep asking them what the plan is, and I don't ever get a satisfying answer.”
On Tuesday, Dye said he planned to head to the local job center for a typing test so he could apply for a job as a 911 dispatcher.
“I really think that’s going to be less stressful than what I’m doing now,” he said.
