Investigation blames U.S. Forest Service for giving Alaska grant used for Roadless Rule fight

A path leads through a dense forest.
The Tongass National Forest is the largest temperate rainforest in the country. With exceptions, the Clinton-era Roadless Rule restricted road building and industrial activity in around 55% of the national forest. Advocates for its repeal said it posed unnecessary hurdles to development projects, like logging, mining, and renewable energy (Photo by Erin McKinstry/KCAW)

A federal watchdog agency said the U.S. Forest Service acted illegally when it awarded a $2 million firefighting grant to the state of Alaska in 2018. The state had asked for the grant to gather input on a proposal to exempt the Tongass National Forest from the Clinton-era Roadless Rule. 

The U.S. Department of Agriculture’s Office of Inspector General issued its report Wednesday. The report says the Forest Service illegally awarded the $2 million to the state through a grant program intended to support fire suppression in state-owned forests. 

A Washington, D.C.-based spokesperson for the Forest Service, Larry Moore, said the money had been set aside for the state. But he said none of it actually ever changed hands. The agency says it’s working with its in-house lawyers to determine how to reallocate the money. 

That means the state is on the hook for any expenses the grant was meant to reimburse: The $2 million grant was to be matched by state funding. It’s not clear how much the state spent gathering input from industry groups and local stakeholders. The governor’s office did not immediately respond to questions for this story.

RELATED: Alaskans react to Trump Administration’s Roadless Rule rollback in the Tongass

The USDA watchdog does not directly accuse state officials of wrongdoing — in fact, documents obtained by Alaska’s Energy Desk show the state told the Forest Service exactly what it was requesting the money for. But investigators said that money never should have been awarded as part of the firefighting grant.

The Alaska Department of Natural Resources said it’s reviewing the findings. Spokesperson Dan Saddler said the agency will work with the Forest Service to ensure grant funds are spent in line with their intended use. He said in an email the Alaska Division of Forestry voluntarily cooperated with the investigation.

Investigators said it’s above-board for the Forest Service to provide funding to gather input on rule changes. But they said awarding that money to the state without informing other interested parties that money was available for that purpose violated federal law and regulations.

Southeast Alaska Conservation Council Executive Director Meredith Trainor said it’s an example of conservation groups and tribes being shut out of the rulemaking process.

“The findings of this independent investigation highlight one of many critical flaws in the Alaska-specific Roadless Rule-making process, and the undue influence that the Trump administration wielded in determining which groups would have access to participate in the public process, and which would be left out,” she said in a statement posted to the group’s website.

She added that the group looked forward to working with the incoming Biden administration to overturn the exemption.

Alaska Wilderness League head Adam Kolton issued a statement which said the investigation shows approval of a roadless rule exemption was “baked into the process once Governor Dunleavy sold Donald Trump on the idea on Air Force One.”

“Alaska officials wanted to change the rule, so the Forest Service gave the state $2 million dollars to convince them to do so,” Kolton wrote.

He said the investigation shows “an egregious lack of respect for Alaska Native voices in Southeast Alaska,” adding the investigation showed the rulemaking process was driven by timber industry interests.

The investigation was prompted by a story last year from former Alaska’s Energy Desk reporter Elizabeth Jenkins. She uncovered documents showing the state had paid the Alaska Forest Association more than $200,000 to influence the rulemaking process. At least one Southeast Alaska tribe was also reimbursed for travel expenses estimated at a few thousand dollars.

After the story was published, two members of Congress requested the investigation.

Last year, state officials including Gov. Mike Dunleavy and Natural Resources Commissioner Corri Feige said the state had not misspent any federal money from the grant.

RELATED: Records show federal government, tasked with rewriting Tongass rules, also funded Alaska timber group

Previous articleBezos charity awards grant to Anchorage Coalition to End Homelessness
Next articleAlaska’s daily COVID-19 count dips over the weekend