Salmon Cheddar Soup with Lobster Mushrooms

Cutterlight Salmon Mushrooms Soup 1

With or without lobster mushrooms (see photo below), this quick, easy seafood soup is one of our wintertime favorites.

The inspiration for this recipe comes from A. J. McClane’s excellent cookbook, North American Fish Cookery. McClane’s original recipe is sans mushrooms and calls for lobster, but the basic stock – milk and cheddar cheese seasoned with nutmeg – lends itself to a variety of innovations. The first time we created this dish we substituted grilled steelhead for the lobster.

Other iterations have featured broiled or grilled salmon, smoked salmon, and Alaska shrimp. In fact, we’ve never used lobster, and although freshly ground nutmeg remains a must in our soup, we usually spice it up with the addition of ground smoked chipotles or other peppers and smoked sea salt. Most recently we made this soup with our own canned smoked red salmon, lobster mushrooms and red bell pepper.

Cutterlight Salmon Mushroom Soup 2

Ready for soup: a lobster mushroom, nutmeg, our own blend of smoked chipotles and other seasoning, and a jar of smoked Copper River red salmon.]

Salmon Cheddar Soup


¼ to ½ pound smoked salmon, grilled salmon, raw salmon, lobster or shrimp cut into ½-inch chunks. (If using raw seafood, allow for a few minutes cooking time in soup till done.)

1¼ cups lobster mushrooms cut into chunks slightly smaller than the seafood. (Optional) These particularly mushrooms work well because they have a firm texture, nice color, and mild flavor.

Part of a red bell pepper cut into thin strips – 4 to 5 strips per serving. Sauté until tender and set aside.

1/4 cup olive oil or butter

3 tbsp flour, as a thickening agent. Rice flour works especially well, but all-purpose flour is fine.

3 cups milk

1¾ cups shredded cheddar cheese

1/8 tsp ground nutmeg

1/2 tsp ground smoked chipotle (optional)

freshly ground black pepper

sea salt or smoked sea salt

paprika (finishing garnish – a dash or 2 per serving)


Place olive oil or butter in a large pot over medium heat.

Add lobster mushrooms, a little salt, a couple grinds of pepper and sauté for about two minutes.

Lower heat and vigorously stir in flour. Then add milk and seasonings, stirring until mixture begins to thicken and becomes hot. Do not allow to boil.

Stir in seafood and cheddar cheese. Give the soup a taste and adjust seasonings as necessary.

Serve piping hot, garnished with a few strips of bell pepper and a dash or two of paprika.

We enjoyed this soup with homemade biscuits.

About Barbra:

I’ve always wanted to be a photographer and a traveler. I have arrived. I get to be outside in one of the most beautiful places in the world… Alaska! In this amazing state, the word “awesome” exists in its intended form. As I travel around Alaska, I am constantly awe-struck.

About Jack:

When I was in third grade, I read Call of the Wild thirteen consecutive times. Not the real version. The version I had was in a volume titled Reader’s Digest Best Loved Books for Young Readers. No matter. For half a year of my life, I was Buck. So began a love affair with a place I’d never seen – Alaska.

Previous articleLegislators Aim To Influence Federal Arctic Policy
Next articleI Can See Russia From Here: 25th Anniversary of the ‘Friendship Flight’